November 14, 1996
By Michael Fumento
The good news is that Secretary of Transportation Federico Pena is finally leaving Washington. The bad news is that he was ever invited to come in the first place and that he is not leaving in disgrace.
On May 11, ValuJet Flight 592 crashed into the Everglades. The next day, practically before the plane had settled on the bottom, Pena rushed to the accident site and proclaimed the airline safe. ValuJet has “in some cases even exceeded the safety standards that we have at the FAA,” he said at a briefing in the Everglades less than 24 hours after the crash. “ValuJet is safe to fly.”
A month later Pena shut that “safe” airline down. But he had long known the airline was a disaster waiting to happen.
On May 2, just nine days before the ValuJet crash, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), a division of Pena’s own Department of Transportation (DOT), produced a report on the safety records of the various airlines. Far from “exceeding” FAA standards, ValuJet’s record was a nightmare.
Of nine so-called “start-up” airlines analyzed, there were six accidents between them. Five of these involved ValuJet. Of accidents labeled “serious,” there were three, ALL involving ValuJet. Compared with the record of the high fare carriers (such as American and United), ValuJet’s accident record was 14 times higher. Its serious accident rate was 32 times higher.
The May 2 report was a mere nine pages long, a five-minute read. Yet Pena appeared on two television shows the day after the ValuJet crash waving those pages and citing them as proof of ValuJet’s safety. “We’ve looked at the safety record of both the lowcost carriers and the socalled higher cost carriers,” he said on the NBC program “Today.” “The safety records are comparable.” He made the same claim on “This Week with David Brinkley.”
But as the report and a special cover attached to the report just for Pena noted, the safety records were equivalent only because so many of the lowcost flights involved Southwest. Pull out Southwest and the lowcost carriers look like a disaster, all because of ValuJet s poor record.
Not only did Pena misrepresent the May 2 report, he must have known about its contents long before then. “I don’t know that it told anybody anything new around here,” said the report’s preparer, FAA analyst Bob Matthews. “That data is pretty easily available to anybody.”
Indeed, FAA documents obtained by the Cleveland Plain Dealer showed at least four inspections of ValuJet since 1993 reporting, “widespread safety problems that were neither fully investigated nor corrected” according to the newspaper. Further, a Defense Department inspection of the airline’s maintenance oversight in August 1995 declared it “Unsatisfactory.”
By February 7 of this year, the situation was so critical that staffers from the FAA Inspector General’s (IG) office met with FAA inspectors over the matter. Documents show the IG’s staff talked about more than a dozen safety problems at the airline. The head of that staff, Mary Schiavo, said later that she decided on that date, “I wouldn’t get on [ValuJet] because of the number of incidents that have been reported.”
Seven days later, an internal FAA memo suggested that ValuJet be shut down pending correction of its safety problems. On May 6, just five days before Flight 592 went down, an FAA preliminary draft report found more than 100 ValuJet safety violations.
Schiavo told me that she had repeatedly attempted to relay her concerns to Pena, going through his chief of staff Ann Bormolini. But Pena claims Bormolini never told him anything.
Goodness, what a strange thing to keep secret from your boss! In any case, immediately after the ValuJet crash, Bormolini quit and scurried back to Denver, where she’s harder to find than Salman Rushdie.
So why did Pena turn a deaf ear to all the warnings about ValuJet? Go back to April 23of this year. The DOT released a report titled “The Low Cost Airline Service Revolution.” In it, Pena claimed that “startup” airlines were providing tremendous savings to the American publicindeed $6.3 billion over the last year. Most of the credit, he said, went to his boss. “These developments are, in large part, the outgrowth of President Clinton’s effort to support new entrant carriers,” Pena boasted.
Yet one of those “startup” airlines was Southwest, which began service back in 1971when Clinton was plotting his presidential run, to be sure, but was still 23 years from his inauguration. Indeed, Southwest accounted for three fourths of the flights of the socalled “startups.” Pull Southwest out of the equation and there’s little left of those “tremendous savings.”
Pull out ValuJet and what’s left is about enough to buy a latte at Starbuck’s.
So Pena didn’t pull out ValuJet; he didn’t ground it.
Now he gets to go home to Denver, probably to do what other former cabinet officials do and become rich by influence pedaling. After all, he served the Clinton Administration well.
But the cost of his PR for Clinton can be measured in human lives. “One hundred and ten people were sacrificed for politics in an election year,” Michael Boyd, president of Aviation
Systems Research Corporation in Golden, Colorado told me. “And Federico Pena has their blood on his hands.”
Incredibly, Pena said Clinton offered him another post in the cabinet, but he turned it down. Then again, maybe it’s not so incredible after all.
Michael Fumento writes on science policy for the Independence Institute, a free-market think tank in Golden. His article “Flight From Reality: The ValuJet CoverUp” appeared in the October 7 New Republic.
This article, from the Independence Institute staff, fellows and research network, is offered for your use at no charge. Independence Feature Syndicate articles are published for educational purposes only, and the authors speak for themselves. Nothing written here is to be construed as necessarily representing the views of the Independence Institute or as an attempt to influence any election or legislative action. Please send comments to Editorial Coordinator, Independence Institute, 14142 Denver West Pkwy., suite 185, Golden, CO 80401 Phone 303-279-6536 (fax) 303-279-4176, or email us.
Copyright 2000 II